#1-4 reviews and/or impressions
Feb. 26th, 2010 11:37 am![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
Crossovers and excerpts from the reviews in my book blog
Wanting Mor by Rukhsana Khan - Hmm, my feelings are a bit mixed for this novel. On one hand I enjoyed this book for giving our main girl Jameela agency in her actions. It’s a bit of a Cinderella story sans the prince, wherein the girl rises from her station and comes into her own. She makes her own choices, her own decisions and I very much appreciated that. I particularly loved how she chose to continue wearing a chadri even after she got surgery done on her cleft lip, how she didn’t choose to wear a chadri because of poor self-image but because she wanted to. However, on the flip side, Jameela herself left me a bit cold. I’m thinking it’s maybe because Jameela is rather cold and standoff-ish towards everyone in the story and by proxy I feel distant from her myself? (more)
A Girl Made of Dust by Nathalie Abi-Ezzi - For me, Adult Lit is all about the writing style, and Abi-Ezzi sure delivers in spades. I love the imagery she has with dust and water, the dried out cactus in the dessert that needs watering. Everything had this parallel to it, almost done cyclically as she switches from dust to water imagery and back. Some of the imagery would be shown in a very direct fashion, like our girl made of dust – who was a girl “covered in sand and dirt”. (more)
Ash by Malinda Lo - Hmm, after having finished reading the novel, my feelings were mixed and I mostly felt torn. One side of me was all super gushy and melting over the Kaisa/Ash pairing, and my other half was left ambivalent about the rest. Thinking back, I think it’s due to my lack of love for the Cinderella tale in general, and the whole pseudo-white medieval setting Lo had going on. I’m not sure how much I was affected by the fact that I read this post by Malinda Lo wherein she said that she imagined her cast as Asian before having read the novel. I tried, and I tried to buy it, that the cast were Asian but I just couldn’t. (more)
Bleeding Violet by Dia Reeves - I just really liked Reeves’ whole approach to this world she created in general, from Hanna’s reactions to seeing stuff (Hanna’s reactions the first few days were like, hmm, I thought I took my pills today, guess they haven’t kicked in yet. *walks past those bloodstained windows like she saw nothing*) to the portrayal of the fantastical in this world. The creatures are batshit scary and feel very real, things that will kill you if you walk down the wrong street. And how the people of the town are deeply influenced by their knowledge of these monsters that lurk their town, how it shapes them from their behavior to what they wear to just, their physical selves and their telltale scars. I bought into the world Reeves’ created completely, and really enjoyed reading about the fantastical side of this novel. (more)
++
Also, I am hosting a book giveaway in which you can win either Exclusively Chloe by J. A. Yang OR Mountain Girl River Girl by Ting-Xing Ye, who are both POC writers. Link's here if anyone's interested. =D
Wanting Mor by Rukhsana Khan - Hmm, my feelings are a bit mixed for this novel. On one hand I enjoyed this book for giving our main girl Jameela agency in her actions. It’s a bit of a Cinderella story sans the prince, wherein the girl rises from her station and comes into her own. She makes her own choices, her own decisions and I very much appreciated that. I particularly loved how she chose to continue wearing a chadri even after she got surgery done on her cleft lip, how she didn’t choose to wear a chadri because of poor self-image but because she wanted to. However, on the flip side, Jameela herself left me a bit cold. I’m thinking it’s maybe because Jameela is rather cold and standoff-ish towards everyone in the story and by proxy I feel distant from her myself? (more)
A Girl Made of Dust by Nathalie Abi-Ezzi - For me, Adult Lit is all about the writing style, and Abi-Ezzi sure delivers in spades. I love the imagery she has with dust and water, the dried out cactus in the dessert that needs watering. Everything had this parallel to it, almost done cyclically as she switches from dust to water imagery and back. Some of the imagery would be shown in a very direct fashion, like our girl made of dust – who was a girl “covered in sand and dirt”. (more)
Ash by Malinda Lo - Hmm, after having finished reading the novel, my feelings were mixed and I mostly felt torn. One side of me was all super gushy and melting over the Kaisa/Ash pairing, and my other half was left ambivalent about the rest. Thinking back, I think it’s due to my lack of love for the Cinderella tale in general, and the whole pseudo-white medieval setting Lo had going on. I’m not sure how much I was affected by the fact that I read this post by Malinda Lo wherein she said that she imagined her cast as Asian before having read the novel. I tried, and I tried to buy it, that the cast were Asian but I just couldn’t. (more)
Bleeding Violet by Dia Reeves - I just really liked Reeves’ whole approach to this world she created in general, from Hanna’s reactions to seeing stuff (Hanna’s reactions the first few days were like, hmm, I thought I took my pills today, guess they haven’t kicked in yet. *walks past those bloodstained windows like she saw nothing*) to the portrayal of the fantastical in this world. The creatures are batshit scary and feel very real, things that will kill you if you walk down the wrong street. And how the people of the town are deeply influenced by their knowledge of these monsters that lurk their town, how it shapes them from their behavior to what they wear to just, their physical selves and their telltale scars. I bought into the world Reeves’ created completely, and really enjoyed reading about the fantastical side of this novel. (more)
++
Also, I am hosting a book giveaway in which you can win either Exclusively Chloe by J. A. Yang OR Mountain Girl River Girl by Ting-Xing Ye, who are both POC writers. Link's here if anyone's interested. =D