sumofparts: picture of books with text 'books are humanity in print' (books)
[personal profile] sumofparts
Sort of a mid-year update. It's been a while since I read some of these so I've just written short impressions but feel free to ask about any of the books.

33. Alentejo Blue by Monica Ali
34. The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao by Junot Diaz
35. The New Moon's Arms by Nalo Hopkinson
36. Valmiki's Daughter by Shani Mootoo
37. Skim written by Mariko Tamaki and illustrated by Jillian Tamaki
38. Henry Chow and other stories edited by R. David Stephens (white)

Alentejo Blue by Monica Ali
This was a well-written book but ultimately disappointing because it just didn't feel like it was going anywhere. Judging from the Goodreads reviews, this was a departure from Brick Lane, which I'll still try eventually.

The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao by Junot Diaz
Like other posters on the comm, I enjoyed this book but it was not without its flaws, which I think everyone else has covered pretty well.

The New Moon's Arms by Nalo Hopkinson
I liked the book but I don't feel everything gelled very well for me. I did like how the main character wasn't always the most sympathetic.

Valmiki's Daughter by Shani Mootoo
Gorgeous writing and evocative descriptions but similar to The New Moon's Arms, something didn't quite click for me. Still, I'd definitely try this author's other books.

Skim written by Mariko Tamaki and illustrated by Jillian Tamaki.
Very detailed and beautiful drawings that really capture the story. Equal credit should be given to author and illustrator.

Henry Chow and Other Stories by various authors, edited by R. David Stephens
Enjoyable but uneven collection of short stories for teenagers. I liked the different story settings and character perspectives. From the Asian Canadian Writers' Workshop.

tags:
a: ali monica, a: hopkinson nalo, a: mootoo shani, a: mariko tamaki, i: tamaki jillian, w-e: stephens r david, short stories, fantasy, lit fic, young adult, coming of age, graphic novel, bangladeshi-british, latin@, dominican-american, caribbean-canadian, jamaican, trinidadian, asian-canadian, chinese-canadian, japanese-canadian, glbt, women writers
zeborah: Zebra against a barcode background, walking on the word READ (read)
[personal profile] zeborah
(A lightly-edited dump of my Goodreads reviews.)

Suckerpunch by Hernandez, David
Hooked me in at the start but the way events followed each other more realistically than determined by a story shape didn't quite work for me. (There was a story shape, it was just more in the gaps between the events.

Dawn (Xenogenesis, #1) by Butler, Octavia E.
So many consent issues... Very good: it's got the claustrophobia, the every-exit-is-a-deadend feel, that I'd normally associate with horror, but manages to retain an optimism about it. The aliens are convincinly alien, and the frustration of their refusal to listen is steadfast without becoming unbelievable.

Straight - A novel in the Irish-Maori tradition by O'Leary, Michael
Straight is the second book in the trilogy; I came to it without having read the first, but felt it stood alone well enough that I had no trouble following the plot. Unfortunately that plot -- the protagonist discovering his father may have been a Nazi, then getting blackmailed and kidnapped by Nazis -- was way too melodramatic for me to take seriously. The prose (especially the dialogue) clunked badly for me, too. I did like the motif of dreamland vs reality vs realism though: that played out well.

My Name Is Number 4 by Ye, Ting-xing
Most disasters bring people and communities together; it seems as if the Cultural Revolution was designed to tear them apart. But this book shows that the struggle to survive and to keep relationships alive is always worth making. --Excuse shallow triteness; reading this book in the aftermath of earthquake I have deeper thoughts on disasters and communities but verbalising is harder especially for fear of simplifying. It was a good book anyway.

People-faces, The by Cherrington, Lisa
This is mostly Nikki's story, of how she's affected by her brother's mental illness and her journey in understanding it - caught between Māori and Pākehā models of understanding - and her journey alongside that of getting to know herself and her strengths. Her grandmother tells her that the dolphin Tepuhi is her guardian, but her grandmother is demonstrably not infallible and with the repeated point that Joshua is of the sea while Nikki is of the land, I think the book bears out that the real/more effective guardian for her is the pīwaiwaka.

Her brother's story is told in the gaps between, and completes the book.

Despite the focus on Nikki and Joshua, we get to see various other points of view, showing the further impact on the rest of their family and their motivations. Some of the point of view shifts are a bit clunky, for example when we get a single scene from the Pākehā doctor's point of view, or just a couple from Nikki's boyfriend.

But this is well-told; the author (of Ngāti Hine) is a clinical psychologist and has worked in Māori mental health services, and the emotions of the story ring very true to me.

Cereus Blooms at Night: A Novel by Mootoo, Shani
This was a fantastic read but at times a very hard one; serious trigger warnings for child abuse (verbal, physical, sexual).

It begins as a beautifully sweet story about racial and sexual and gender identity; about family separations made by force or by choice, and about forbidden liaisons both healthy and unhealthy. Set in the country of Lantanacamara, colonised by the Shivering Northern Wetlands -- more an open code than fantasy countries -- the story focuses on three generations of locals, straight and gay, cis and trans, more and less inculturated by Wetlandish education. The narrator begins by disclaiming any significant role in the story; instantly I want to know more about him, and (though he was right that this is more Mala's story) I was not disappointed.

The main story, switching among its several timelines, grows darker and winds tighter with perfect pacing. Revelations are neither too delayed nor too forced. And as it heads towards the catastrophe we've foreseen, through horror worse than we could have imagined at the start, so it brings us towards its equally inevitable -- and no less satisfying -- eucatastrophe.
[identity profile] seekingferret.livejournal.com
44) Gil's All Fright Diner by A. Scott Martinez

The second book by Martinez I've read and reviewed here. Whereas, The Automatic Detective is SF noir, this one is comic horror. It's not so much my genre, and this was not so much the novel for me.

It had its bright spots. Vampirism as metaphor for lust is a theme that's been well-plumbed over the past few years, but it was refreshing to see someone use Vampirism to explore the fact that sex can be funny. Earl the Vampire was by far the novel's most compelling character, and Martinez did a lot of good things to put him in situations one doesn't usually find a vampire in. But otherwise, I don't know... not a whole lot of substance here, just goofy adventures with werewolves and ghosts and witches.


45) Among the Believers by V. S. Naipaul

A really unique travelogue from Naipaul's 1981 tour of four non-Arab Muslim countries: Iran, Pakistan, Malaysia, and Indonesia. Naipaul, a Trinidadian of Indian Hindu descent who holds British citizenship, is an interesting outsider to tell the story. On the one hand, he has little enough experience with Islam that he can ask questions with near-childlike naivete. On the other hand, he has enough experience with the world of the colonized to know the right questions to ask.

I'd heard Naipaul's reputation as a particularly strong stylist, but to be honest, I wasn't particularly struck by his prose. It was serviceable, journalistic, and direct. What I really liked was his perspective, which was aimless, infinitely curious, and driven purely by self-interest. In Malaysia he detours from a planned visit to a particular region because the monsoon rains bother him. He makes no plans to return later, just cuts the trip out of his tour. The ever-present distortion of his own perspective reminds us that most outside visitors to these regions have an agenda. They're there to see something in particular, to record it, and to leave. Naipaul's just there to see whatever comes his way, and tell everyone what he saw, what interested him. One of the book's best passages, in my mind, is when Naipaul discusses his approach to curiosity with a Pakistani journalist who can't quite make sense out of it.

Naipaul is sharply critical of many aspects of Islamic culture (and already, the book I've picked up for #46 has attempted to answer some of his criticisms) for offering no substantive solutions to the poverty, injustice, and inequalities that permeate these societies. He describes the dream of an Islamic society as one driven by vague and elusive promises of a divine law whose shape its dreamers cannot clearly envision, or would not desire if they could. He can be occasionally kind of mean-spirited about this, picking fights with people who are just trying to get on with their lives because he finds their worldviews alien.

But Naipaul has an odd sort of cover: his tour of the Islamic world was so haphazard and random and anecdotal that he can't possibly claim to have a valid read on the society. In the Indonesia section he describes visiting the pesantren, cooperative unstructured Islamic schools. His initial visit finds him hearing them described by a whimsical teacher who refuses to call himself a teacher, and he is shocked and appalled by a school system that appears to "teach villagers how to be villagers", as he puts it. But a later visit, impelled by his guide's insistence that he has misunderstood the system, reveals that he has in fact misunderstood the system. The Islamic world is too large and complicated for Naipaul to easily master its nuances. And I kind of appreciate the fact that he just rolls with this and tries to do his best anyway. But if there's a problem with the book, it's the tedious concluding chapter when he mostly fails to make any sense at all about where the Islamic world is heading.

Profile

50books_poc: (Default)
Writers of Color 50 Books Challenge

June 2025

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718 192021
22232425262728
2930     

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 29th, 2025 08:45 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios