Thanks to those who gave input on how all y'all want the LJ and DW instances of the community to relate to each other; I'm interpreting the quietness of that discussion as a sign that most people are pretty okay with the thoughts already there.
Based on that, what we're going with for now is to run the two comms as sister communities under one management. We're going to strive for no duplication of new content between the two communities, so that members can follow both without being spammed with content they already saw. (Which we won't be able to pull off perfectly, because--) We're also going to have Dreamwidth act as a permanent archive of all activity at both platforms, by regularly importing the LiveJournal community into the Dreamwidth one.
So, the details:
As always, if anything above seems unclear, incorrect, unworkable, or a bad idea, please let us know. I'll be updating the FAQ and community sidebars a bit later.
(x-post)
Based on that, what we're going with for now is to run the two comms as sister communities under one management. We're going to strive for no duplication of new content between the two communities, so that members can follow both without being spammed with content they already saw. (Which we won't be able to pull off perfectly, because--) We're also going to have Dreamwidth act as a permanent archive of all activity at both platforms, by regularly importing the LiveJournal community into the Dreamwidth one.
So, the details:
- Mod-posts will be cross-posted.
- Do not cross-post book reviews, etc. Please presume that people who want to see the posts being made on the other site are either already subscribed on the other site or are following the RSS feed.
- Feeds of the Livejournal Community:
http://community.livejournal.com/50books_poc/data/rss (for feedreaders)
50books_poc_feed (for dreamwidth users) - Feeds of the Dreamwidth Community:
http://50books-poc.dreamwidth.org/data/rss (for feedreaders)
50bookspocdw (for livejournal users)
Note concerning the feed of the Dreamwidth Community: the community importer retains the dates of the original posts when it runs an import; the RSS feed syndicates all recent-date posts, and does so as it comes to notice their existence. Thus, it appears that on days that we run the importer, the DW RSS feed will notice all recent originally-on-LJ posts, and publish them to the RSS feed. Which means that yes, on days that we run the importer, you'll see a 'burp' of recent-ish posts to the LJ community popping up in the feed of the DW community.
We don't know how to make that not happen. We're hoping that, since the community importer is brand new and there are presumably other communities dealing with this, that there will be some demand for a technological tweak to make that not happen. We'll keep you updated. If it proves to be intolerable, let us know. - Commenting on the other platform: Both Dreamwidth and Livejournal accept OpenID logins; both Dreamwidth and Livejournal logins act as OpenID logins. Which means you can use your LiveJournal ID to comment on Dreamwidth posts, and vice versa.
LiveJournal's OpenID FAQ.
Dreamwidth's OpenID FAQ.
Notice that both sites will send you notifications of replies to your comments, if you give them an email address to send those replies to. They'll also let you have a few userpics, and some other "almost like having a username on that site" kinds of privileges.
At the moment, Dreamwidth is also letting people create accounts without an invite code, if you'd rather just have a Dreamwidth account. You can also get invite codes at
dw_codesharing. (Or ask me; I've got a handful I haven't used, and am happy to give them to 50books-poc folks.) - Imported posts: LiveJournal posts imported to Dreamwidth are attributed to an OpenID account associated with your LiveJournal username. Dreamwidth is working on a way to let Dreamwidth users "claim" their OpenID Livejournal accounts, but that's not yet live.
(More info about community importing: Happy Holidays, Have a Shiny Thing; Community Importing is Live; Community Import FAQ.)
As always, if anything above seems unclear, incorrect, unworkable, or a bad idea, please let us know. I'll be updating the FAQ and community sidebars a bit later.
(x-post)